Sustainable Food

School Lunch: Bad On Purpose

Published May 27, 2009 @ 08:58AM PT

Donut bacon burger; by Marshall Astor, Food PornographerThis Los Angeles Times article does a decent job laying out the hurdles schools face in providing healthy meals for students, but I've got a little quibble:

... The U.S. government spends about $11.7 billion a year on school programs that provide lunch for over 30 million children and breakfast for more than 10 million -- but has not updated nutritional standards and meal requirements since 1995.

States have tried to act without waiting for the federal government. As of last August, 18 states had adopted tougher nutritional standards than the U.S. government -- but most lack enforcement power and cannot punish noncompliance, says the Trust for America's Health, a nonprofit organization that works to raise community health standards. ...

When I wrote about the garbage in school lunches last week, I linked to a Mother Jones article that tells the story of that mid-1990s standards process, and the railroading of Ellen Haas, nutritional reformer appointed by President Clinton, by food service industry lobbyists and commodity groups:

... Haas soon found herself frozen out by legislators and abandoned by the Clinton administration. Says a key USDA staffer, "We were told by the White House, ‘You have to live with this.'"

Although Congress did set fat limits for school lunches, it created no effective mechanism for reaching those standards -- and no penalty for failing. ...

The crappy food that kids are served at school is not an accident. The crappy food that's advertised to them (and everyone) on television and any other waking moment by people with psychology and marketing PhDs, that's not an accident, either. The proliferation of cheap burgers and nachos, the banishment of carrots and leafy greens to the upscale neighborhoods, this is not an accident either.

Our food system is the way that it is on purpose and it can only get better the same way: on purpose.

As fellow Change.org blogger, Clay Burell, noted on the Education blog, the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine has a petition going to ask for more vegetarian and vegan options in school lunches.

They don't mean fries, cheese pizza and mushy, canned green beans, either. (Good grief, I hated the canned green beans when I was a kid.)

I'm not one to insist that people swear off meat and cheese, but the stuff they serve at most schools ... whatever people can eat, they need fresh fruits and vegetables, whole grains, food that very obviously came from a recently living plant. For kids, doubly so.

Please ask for more vegetarian and vegan options in school lunches, today.

(Photo credit: Marshall Astor on Flickr.

Share this Post

Related Posts

Comments (4)

  1. Stephanie Ernst

    I'm amused--three of us at Change.org have now posted on PCRM's lunch campaign. They actually have the petition up here at Change.org too: http://www.change.org/healthy_school_lunches/actions

    Posted by Stephanie Ernst on 05/27/2009 @ 10:34AM PT

  2. Natasha Chart

    Thanks for noting that, glad we can be in agreement on something :)

    I mean, I remember school food, it was an abomination. It wasn't surprising at all to grow up and find out not only how bad it was, but that in many places it's gotten worse - they didn't used to be able to have the vending machines in my school districts. You could still buy soda or ice cream after lunch when I went, but you had to stand in a separate line and it took a long time so that was a bit of a deterrent.

    The next step will be pure corn syrup IVs that the kids can just wander off down the halls and sit in class with. Or they could just start giving them direct subcutaneous fat injections. Cut out the middle bits, you know?

    Anyway, it's an indisputably messed up situation. So three posts about it probably doesn't come close to being enough.

    Posted by Natasha Chart on 05/27/2009 @ 10:52AM PT

  3. Reply to thread
  4. Sue G.

    When I was in (a small) grade school, we had cooks who made "home-cooked" meals for us in a real kitchen.  I suppose we had white bread, etc., but that's what people of my generation thought was "the thing".  But it was as good as our mothers made back in the day.  When I was in high school, I think they also cooked the food.  So it wasn't too bad.  But I usually opted for an ice cream sandwich or something other than a hot lunch.  
    But when my kids were in school, I got the impression that the food was made somewhere else and reheated like "death-warmed-over" in the cafeteria's microwave or in those containers that pizza delivery people use to keep pizzas warm.  It sounded pretty disgusting, when the kids would tell me what was on the menu.  I know there was a lot of cheese and grease, like re-heated grill cheese sandwiches or cheeseburgers that were stacked on top of each other, and semi-smashed.  I could only guess that it was government surplus, which I suspect is all bad quality that doesn't make it to the grocery store shelves.  And in my opinion, that is just one reason why I think the subsidy program needs a major overhaul -- because the worst of what the government pays for seems to get dumped on the school lunch programs.  

    Why subsidize garbage?

    (Just a personal opinion.)

    Posted by Sue G. on 05/28/2009 @ 10:46AM PT

  5. Natasha Chart

    "Death warmed over" sounds about right for what I remember. Even the things that looked like they'd been alive once had been totally zombified.

    Posted by Natasha Chart on 05/28/2009 @ 11:35AM PT

  6. Reply to thread

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

Author

Twitter Feed

Natasha Chart

Natasha is an amateur eater with severe snarkolepsy and a c. 2002 blogging habit. She had a fabulous time studying ecological agriculture and policy at The Evergreen State College, and even did her homework while writing at various times for pacificviews.org, boomantribune.com, and mydd.com.

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.